Current issues, feedback & complaints on public services in Malaysia
ON Dec 10, 2007, I took the Express Wau train from Kuala Lumpur Sentral to Wakaf Baru, Kelantan.
Before departing, KTMB announced that the train would only go as far as the Gua Musang station because the railway track at Manik Urai was impassable owing to a derailed train a few days earlier.
With the assurance that on reaching Gua Musang, passengers would be transported by buses to destinations further north, I boarded the train. The journey from Kuala Lumpur Sentral to Jerantut railway station was fine.
At the Jerantut railway station (at 4.30am), we learnt that the train could not proceed because of landslides in Kerambit (between Jerantut and Kuala Lipis).
KTMB staff in Jerantut and on board the train assured us that we could continue our journey by 8am.
But it was only at 10am that the Express Wau resumed its journey and discovered that the track was blocked by new landslides.
The train returned to Jerantut station, where it had become crowded because passengers from Express Wau were joined by passengers from Express Timuran from Singapore to Tumpat.
While little was being done to cater to the needs of the passengers, the canteen operator was doing brisk business by charging RM5 for a plate of rice and RM2 for each handphone that was being charged at her canteen.
KTMB said the district of Jerantut had been cut off from other districts, that the floodwaters were rising everywhere, and there was no alternative transport except by the KTM trains.
We had no choice but to wait. Patience turned to impatience, and impatience to panic at 5pm, when passengers scrambled to get their luggage from the trains and rushed to board buses that were reportedly going to take us to Kuala Lipis.
But there was no official announcement from any KTMB staff to verify whether it was true or not.
At 6pm, three buses arrived. It was drizzling and many of us were drenched while walking to the buses, which were parked quite a distance from the station.
At 7.20pm, another five buses arrived and the same mad rush went on until all the buses left at 7.45pm. However, hundreds of us were still stranded at the station.
Having spent almost 16 hours waiting and receiving only a packet drink, courtesy of KTMB, the crowd turned ugly.
Several packets of rice had been distributed but this was not announced, though we could see some KTMB personnel going for it.
When asked, an Express Timuran worker rudely told us that we had to get it ourselves.
Initially, we were also not allowed to use the facilities at the Jerantut station.
It was only later that the station master relented to the demands of the passengers, and reluctantly allowed us to use the VIP room and washrooms.
While the passengers suffered and were kept in the dark about the whole situation, no KTMB staff from its headquarters were present to monitor the situation.
KTMB officers themselves were at loggerheads — each wanting to have their final say to settle matters.
At 8pm, the station master announced that the tracks to Kuala Lipis had been cleared.
Again, there was another mad rush to board the Express Timuran train by the remaining passengers, who had not got on the buses earlier.
We reached Kuala Lipis station at 10pm, where some of the passengers who had left by bus earlier came on board.
I met an elderly couple who said they had an awful experience on the bus.
There were no KTMB officers escorting them and the old school buses had been driven by young men, who did not even know the roads to Kuala Lipis.
It was indeed very lucky that the eight buses which ferried the passengers on that day did not meet with an accident along the way.
Finally, as someone who has been using the KTMB train services since schooldays in the early 70s,
I think it is high time that something is done to improve train services.
This unfortunate incident should prompt KTMB to revamp its train services on the East Coast, a sector that has not seen much progress compared with the West Coast.
NORIDA MOHD HUSSAIN, Kota Baru
Source: NST – January 23, 2008
TwoSen is updated daily with letters written to newspapers in Malaysia.
We publish all the letters here giving you a single source to keep track of current issues, feedback and complaints on public services. We do not alter the content of the letters, but do allow comments to facilitate positive discussions.
Layang Johor
January 24th, 2008 at 11:12 am
I really sympathize with the experience of Norida. I stayed in Layang-Layang Johor and work in Johor Bahru since 1990. I travel to visit my parents very often, almost every weekend in the past, via KTMB train service. I grew up in the shop house near the train station in Layang-layang. I experienced and used the KTMB service since I was a very young kid.
In the 70-80s, the train service is actually better. The station master and staffs are friendly and helpful. 5 minutes before train arrived, the master will ring the belt to inform everyone that the train is coming. The train service was very frequent and on time. Many folks in my home town travel through the train service to other town. In addition, KTM offers a lot of freight service to carry cement, fertilizer, etc through the train network.
In the late 80s and early 90, KTM goes through the privatization. KTM upgraded their train system by enhancing the communication system using the electronic systems. The tracks were upgraded and there is a planned to install dual track rail between JB to north bound service. KTM was more sensitive to the business needs. With the high ridership between Singapore to Kluang, KTM started additional short haul services for all the stations along Kluang to Singapore, in additional to the express train service. Service was improving, there are 3 North and 3 South bound trains service between Kluang and Singapore; however, there is a big drop in freight services of KTM. I had hardly see any freight train going through KTM tracks.
Toward the mid 90s, KTM starts to having problem. The weekend business for passengers traveled to and from Singapore have increased. The weekend trains were packed with passengers. The capacity cannot cope up with the ridership. Passengers are holding to the door of the train in order to get to the train service to JB and singapore. The over crowded train service on weekend were so bad that there were 1 casualty where a young man who stand at the door were hit by the bridge when the train crossing the river between Kulai to Johor Bahru. KTM continues to ignore the over crowded train services.
Unannounced delay is a norm. We could wait for 1-2 hours in the train stations for the train service. There wasn’t a single announcement. When the train arrived, the train was so packed with passengers. To get into the train, some passengers hv to stand and hold the door railing. The services were really bad. KTM continued to ignore the overcrowded train issue til early 2000.
With 2007 economy down turn and political water issue with Singapore, KTMB started to cut the train service from at least 6 train services to just 4 train services (inclusive of north and south bound train service), although ridership was very high on the weekend. All high ridership train services were canceled. The new trains that bought to service Singapore-Kluang was abandon in the spare tracks in Layang-layang train station.
To make the matter worst, the KTMB introduced new train on the route; however, the new train aircon broke down so frequent that people inside the train is like riding an oven train. The train was jammed pack with passengers. The train has very small window to allow wind to comes in. The temperature inside the train is a few degree higher than outside of the train. The train selection was so poor and dangerous to the passenger. I had seen children and old people get sick on the train. KTM did not take any action.
The train service manned by the train driver and the station master was very poor. The train can be stopped for extra 10-15 minutes to allow the train drivers and the ticket inspectors to buy food at the drink stall at the train station. There is no urgency for the train driver and the station master to keep up with the schedule. The train station master can chat with the train driver or the ticket inspector and ignore the passengers. Many lost hours incurred by the indisciplined station masters and the train staffs.
Today, the train service between my home town to JB has been cut to only 2 train services (1 north bound and 1 south bound trains). The train timing and schedule continue to be poor.
KTM also seems to have problem with spare train engine and maintenance is a problem. When the train breakdown, it takes a long time for KTM to get the workable engine train. During holiday, delay by hours and unannounced break down delay were the norm of the KTM train service.
I grow up together with KTMB train service. I have seen KTMB service continue to dropped significantly since I started using the train service as a kid. These problems continue to deteriorated. Thus, I do not think KTMB will improve in the near future given the track record of the deterioration of their services. If KTMB cannot run a short haul train service effectively and successfully, then, KTMB will not be able to run an effective train services for the express and longer haul services.
It is also very sad that KTM, as a major public transportation company, has not been able to serve people living in the rural area well but also not able to keep up with the express train service. The privatization of KTMB has not brought an improvement to KTMB train service. The government should consider taking back the KTMB privatization.
saiful bahari
January 25th, 2008 at 9:53 am
i share the same ordeal. wrote it down at my blog (http://www.banyu.org/blog/index.php/2007/12/01/a-night-with-a-stupefied-train/). was pissed with ktmb service. Love the concept of travelling by train, but loathe ktmb poor service.